Financial Analysis of Tiles vs Other Roofing Materials in DFW, Texas

Are you a homeowner or property developer in Dallas-Fort Worth who needs to choose the right material for their roofing system?

The decision is crucial; it includes factors such as aesthetics, performance, longevity, and lastly, cost. 

We understand roofing is a significant investment for your property. 

The wrong choice of materials and contractors can lead to unexpected expenses down the line. 

In this blog post, we provide:

  • An in-depth investment analysis.
  • Focusing on the cost comparison between tiles and other roofing materials in Dallas-Fort Worth, Texas. 

We break down the numbers and equip you with the insights needed to choose the optimal roofing solution for your property. 

If you need help with this process, you can contact us at 844-893-7326 or book an appointment with us directly. 

Tile Roofing Cost in Dallas-Fort Worth, TX

According to NRCIA, on average, tile roofing replacement cost around $8,000 to $23,000.

The cost of any tile roof will depend on several factors, such as the material you have chosen and the complexity of your roofing system; 

  • How steep is it? 
  • What’s the size of the roof?

The steeper it is, the more you can expect to pay for it. 

Similarly, the larger the roof is, the more you can expect to pay for it. 

And most importantly, tile is not an average material. 

It is the kind of material that requires a different level of expertise and knowledge, for which you have to pay a premium. 

In this table, we provide a much more in-depth analysis of how investment in other tile roofing materials is required. 

Type of MaterialAverage Material Cost (Per Square Foot)Average Installation Cost (Per Square Foot)Total Cost (2,000 sq roof size)
Concrete$2 to $4$7 to $9$14,000 to $18,000
Clay$3 to $7$8 to $22 $16,000 to $44,000
Terracotta$5 to $10$10 to $25$20,000 to $50,000
Slate$5 to $30$10 to $45$20,000 to $90,000
Metal$6 to $15$11 to $30$22,000 to $60,000
Composite$7 to $11$12 to $26$24,000 to $52,000

Data Source: Architectural Digest

Unlike other materials, tiles have their unique styles as well. 

The type of style you choose will add some extra dollars to the overall investment. 

As you can see, barrel tile is the cheapest option available, while interlocking is the most expensive. 

On the other hand, this table will illustrate how much each tile style costs in comparison to others.

Type of StyleAverage Cost (Per Square Feet)
Barrel Tile$3 to $5
Plain/Flat$8 to $9
Pantile$8 to $10
Spanish$8 to $10
French$9 to $11
Mission/Double Roman$9 to $11
Riviera$9 to $11
Interlocking$10 to $13

Data Source: Architectural Digest

Other Roofing Materials

Tiles fall under the roofing category more on the luxury end.

Most materials can’t be held in comparison with it, as it is so different in terms of visuals and financial perspective. 

As a result, it translates into different total investment and maintenance packages. 

And it will also differ in terms of how well it will perform and how long it will last. 

Here is a table where we provide an in-depth analysis of each roofing material option.

Name of Roofing MaterialCost Per Square Foot (Including the Installation)Total Cost (2,000 sq roof size)
Aluminum Shingles$8.50 to $13.75$17,000 to $27,500
Architectural/Premium Asphalt Shingles $4.50 to $8.25$9,000 to $16,500
Basic Asphalt Shingles $4.25 to $4.95$8,500 to $9,900
Cedar Shingles or Shakes$8 to $14.30$16,000 to $28,600
Corrugated Metal $5.50 to $11.50$11,000 to $23,000
Standing Seam Metal $10 to $17.05$20,000 to $34,100
Steel Shingles $8.00 to $12.65$16,000 to $25,300
Flat Roofing Materials (EPDM, PVC, Mod Bit)$5.50 to $7.50$11,000 to $15,000

Data Source: thisoldhouse

However, there is one factor to consider. 

In the table, some materials require less investment than others. 

On paper, it looks good and is a cost-effective solution. 

But for such materials as basic asphalt shingles or corrugated metal, down the line, you may have to pay extra bucks for the maintenance cost. 

In comparison, standing seam metal will easily withstand extreme weather in Dallas-Fort Worth.

However, standing seams will require very little maintenance but require an appropriate investment in the very beginning. 

Therefore, more than just making decisions based on finances is needed; you also need to include other relevant details. 

Local Factors to Consider

Current Roof Condition

The current status of your roofing system can have an impact on your overall budget. 

The reason why? 

Through the inspection, if we figure out that your roofing deck is damaged and requires a complete overhaul, we have to do that before installing tiles. 

Not only will we remove the existing roofing material, but we will replace an entire deck. 

It will add to the overall budget, but it’s an important measure to take. 

A roofing deck is the foundation of any roofing system. 

If we install tiles on a damaged material or deck, later down the line, it will result in leakage and damage to the material. 

In the end, you will have to replace it. 

Weather Conditions

In the Dallas-Fort Worth area, weather conditions are very unforgiving towards roofs. 

It will surely test every roofing system to its absolute limits. 

Texas is known as the state that experiences the most hail storms annually every single year, according to Insurance Information Institute.

Recently, as reported by Dallas News, hail damage has caused billions of dollars in property damage in Texas alone. 

That is why it is so crucial to have a roof that is reliable and can withstand such harsh climates year in and year out. 

More than just choosing the material is required; you need a contractor who can execute the project properly to provide such a service.  

Availability of Installers 

When it comes to installing tile roofing materials, it is crucial to choose someone who has the knowledge and expertise about it. 

Unlike other basic materials like asphalt or other flat roof options, it requires basic skills and knowledge.

In tile installation, you are dealing with material that is made from natural and recyclable materials. 

It is required to be installed with attention to detail and care. 

One silly mistake and your roof might look differently than expected.

In the Dallas-Fort Worth area, the availability of such installers who can execute on such high levels is less than you think. 

But at ADC, we have completed several tile roofing projects for our client in the past decade with absolute ease. 

Labor Costs 

After materials, in any roofing project, labor costs account for the majority of the project.

As stated earlier, tiles are a very different material that requires a different kind of specialization of skills to execute such projects. 

And for that reason, you have to pay a premium for it. 

From our experience, labor costs account for at least 40 to 60 percent of the entire tile roofing project.

Conclusion: Tiles is a Suitable Option in Dallas-Fort Worth, TX

As a property owner or investor, tile roofing is an investment that can significantly enhance your property financially as well as visually. 

Not only that, it also can battle the harsh weather climates that our city throws at our roof consistently every year. 
If you are in need of a tile roofing service for your property, feel free to contact us at 844-893-7326, or you can book an appointment.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *